7 Greatest Pizza Stone Substitutes

7 Greatest Pizza Stone Substitutes

Rate this post

To be honest, a pizza stone is going to be your best choice for baking pizza. Hence, if you want to create pizzas on a frequent basis, don’t be afraid to invest on a pizza stone. But what if you don’t have one and need to bake a pizza right away? Are you out of options?

The good news is that there are several pizza stone replacements. The number one item is a baking sheet, which virtually everyone owns in their kitchen. Cast iron skillets, pizza steels, dutch ovens, and cake pans may also be used to complete the task.

Hello there! My name is Shea, and although I like using my pizza stone, I wasn’t always the proud owner of this useful piece of equipment. But, I have used numerous of these solutions and they work well.

Let’s talk about the greatest pizza stone replacements!

7 Best Substitutes for Pizza Stone

As previously said, I strongly advise purchasing a pizza stone. Pizza stones are particularly intended to produce a beautiful, lightweight, and crispy crust similar to that seen in a professional pizza restaurant. In the meanwhile, try one of these fantastic alternatives.

1. Pizza Steel

Pizza steel is quite similar to a pizza stone, however it has a few advantages. For those who don’t know what a pizza is, here’s a hint: it’s made of steel. It’s also a lot simpler to clean.

2. Baking Sheet

A baking sheet is another excellent replacement. I’ve never encountered someone who didn’t possess a baking sheet, making it a cheap and convenient substitute for pizza stones.

If you’re looking for a unique way to eat your veggies, here is the place to go. It may also be used to bake pizza.

Just turn your baking sheet upside down and place it on the bottom rack of the oven while it warms up. Then, just like a pizza stone or pizza steel, slide your pizza straight on top. The finished product is stunning.

3. Cast Iron Skillet

A cast-iron skillet is another common household item. Although we usually use this useful device to prepare omelets or pan-fry salmon filets, it may also be used as a pizza stone alternative.

You may cook the pizza directly on the stove or in the oven when using a cast-iron pan. Make sure the cast iron skillet is oven-safe before you begin.

Remember that a pizza cooked in a cast-iron pan will be smaller than those baked on a pizza stone, pizza steel, baking sheet, and so on. Who doesn’t like personal pan pizzas? Make plenty for the whole family to enjoy!

4. Dutch Oven

A dutch oven is a little bigger than a cast iron skillet but still a feasible alternative. Some of you may be familiar with the term “Dutch oven,” which refers to someone’s ability to bake something wonderful.

Bear in mind that dutch ovens are often large and cumbersome. This might make it more difficult to insert your pizza dough inside and remove the dutch oven from the oven.

5. Cake Tin

If you don’t already have a cake pan, you should get one, particularly if you intend to visit our baking site on a frequent basis! Cake tins are really inexpensive, so they will not break the bank. Not only that, but they are ideal for baking a variety of cakes.

So let us return to the topic of preparing pizza rather than cake. When you don’t have a pizza stone, your cake pan might come in helpful. Just turn the cake pan upside down to increase surface area and make it simpler to slide the pizza on and off.

The good thing about cake pans is that they are shockingly similar to pizza pans, which are also an excellent substitute for pizza stones. A cake tin turned upside down looks and functions like a pizza pan. Why not have both?

6. Grill

Not everyone has a backyard wood-fired pizza oven. (And if you do, we are envious). If you don’t already have one of these lovely instruments, I strongly advise you to do so. They can make pizza like you’ve never had before.

Meanwhile, you can rely on your reliable barbecue. Although you won’t get the same smokey flavor, there’s something about a nicely scorched crust that will have you drooling. Try it instead of using a pizza stone and an oven.

7. DIY Pizza Stone

I’ll be honest: I’m not that crafty, especially when it comes to crafting anything like this. So, if you like doing things yourself, why not make your own pizza stone? Most are created using unglazed quarry tiles and a little elbow grease.


Pizza stones work like magic, but they aren’t required. You can still create some of the greatest pizza you’ve ever had without using a high-quality substitute. Continue reading these FAQs if you still have queries about the finest pizza stone replacements.

What is better than a pizza stone?

It really depends on who you ask. Some individuals like pizza stones, while others believe pizza steels are superior. Pizza stones, in my opinion, are the greatest. Nonetheless, it is a matter of personal choice. Why not try both and discover which one you prefer?

Can I use a tile instead of a pizza stone?

Yes, you can bake your pizzas on tile instead of a pizza stone. I’ve never done this before, so I can’t comment on how well it works. If you want to give it a go, here’s a terrific site that will teach you how. You can also use tile to construct a pizza stone.

What is the best material for a pizza stone?

Pizza stones are constructed from a variety of materials such as clay, cast iron, ceramic, and cordierite. Clay, cast iron, and cordierite are the greatest materials, according to me, since they are less prone to breaking. Ceramic is the most prone to cracking, therefore I would avoid it.

Can I use granite as a pizza stone?

Indeed, granite can be used as a pizza stone! Granite is reasonably priced and heat resistant, making it an excellent choice for baking pizzas in the oven or on the grill. Granite does not rust, and all you need to do is coat it with oil before baking.

Final Words

A pizza stone is useful, although it is not required for baking pizzas. Pizza steels, baking sheets, cast iron skillets, dutch ovens, cake pans, grills, and even DIY pizza stones are all good replacements for pizza stones. Everything works well!

Have you ever had to make do without a pizza stone? Which of them do you prefer? Did you utilize anything else that wasn’t listed? Share your thoughts in the comments box below!


What can be used in place of a pizza stone?

5 Pizza Stone Inverted Baking Sheet Options. Why I Don’t Use a Pizza Baking Stone.
Pan made of cast iron. Our skillet pizza is cooked in a cast iron pan on the stovetop, but you can also bake it in a cast iron pan to get a crispy pizza crust.
Steel is a kind of steel that is used to make pizzas.
Aug 31, 2022

What material makes the best pizza stone?

The #1 Pizza Stone’s essential element is cordierite stone, a mineral known for its ability to tolerate high temperatures without experiencing thermal shock. Solido also incorporates a “heat spiral” on the bottom of these pizza stones.

What can replace a baking stone?

a bread mold…. a cookie sheet or a flat baking pan.
Things to Look for in Terracotta Tiles While Making Bread…. Fire Bricks.
More to come…
8 Alternatives To Baking Stone\sBaking On A Slab Of Steel. A steel baking surface is perhaps the greatest or one of the finest ways to bake bread. … Dutch Oven… Pirex… Bread Cloche… Baking Pan

Can I cook pizza on a cookie sheet?

If all you have is a light-colored baking sheet, you can cook pizza on it. Just raise the oven temperature to 510°F (or higher if feasible) and bake your pizza for 5 to 10 minutes longer, monitoring the bottom every few minutes to ensure it’s uniformly browned but not scorched.

What is the best surface to cook pizza on?

Food Network Kitchen Tested the 5 Best Pizza Stones and Steels
Overall winner: Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan with Seasoning.
The Original Baking Steel is the best pizza steel.
Emile Henry French Ceramic Pizza Stone is the best ceramic pizza stone.
Cuisinart Three-Piece Pizza Grilling Set is the best pizza stone set.
Additional details…•July 12, 2022

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top