Can You Substitute Margarine for Butter in Cookies?

Can You Substitute Margarine for Butter in Cookies?

Rate this post

Butter and margarine. They have the same appearance, behave the same, smell the same, and even taste identical. With that in mind, many people question whether they can just replace butter in cookies with margarine, and the answer is yes. You may substitute margarine, however high-fat margarine is recommended.

Hi! My name is Shea, and I used to love margarine. I now appreciate the deliciousness and richness of genuine butter. However, I completely understand the temptation to use margarine. In any case, I’ve used margarine instead of butter in cookies several times.

If you prefer margarine to butter or don’t have any on hand, this article will explain why you can simply substitute margarine for butter in cookies. It will also provide some other useful information, such as the difference between these components and which kind of margarine to use.

Whos ready to bake some margarine cookies?

Difference Between Margarine and Butter

Can You Use Margarine Instead of Butter in Cookies

Before you can decide whether or not to use margarine instead of butter in cookies, you must first grasp the difference between the two.

  • Butter is a dairy product that is heavy in fat, mostly saturated fat. It also has around 20% water and a few additional milk proteins.
  • Margarine Margarine, on the other hand, is made from vegetable oils. It includes more water and polyunsaturated fats than butter.

With that in mind, it’s simple to understand why margarine is healthier than butter, particularly for your heart. Of course, this is only true if you use a container of margarine that is free of trans fats or has a low trans fat content.

Because margarine is the healthier alternative, it’s simple to understand why someone might change actual butter for a margarine substitute in a cookie. Can it be done, and what will happen as a result?

Can You Use Margarine Instead of Butter in Cookies?

Can You Use Margarine Instead of Butter in Cookies

Yes, you may use margarine for butter in cookies. It’s also quite simple to accomplish, given the 1:1 ratio. So, if your chocolate chip cookie recipe asks for one cup of butter, use one cup of margarine instead.

How Does Margarine Affect Cookies?

So you may use margarine for butter in cookies. Great. Isn’t that it? Is there nothing else to think about? No, not exactly. You must recognize that butter and margarine produce somewhat different outcomes (though both are delicious).

Cookies with butter have an extraordinarily rich and delicious taste that no other ingredient alternative can match. And, since it melts slowly, it has the ideal consistency and texture. Cookies spread out just enough to be crispy while remaining ooey-gooey.

Margarine, on the other hand, functions similarly. However, since margarine cookies have more water and less fat, they spread wider and become thinner. As a consequence, the cookie becomes crisper. Because of this, it is easier to burn cookies while using margarine, so use caution!

Choosing the Right Margarine is Key

It is strongly advised to use stick margarine. Why? Because of the greater fat content. However, bear in mind that stick margarine contains trans fats, which many individuals want to avoid.

So why do I suggest it? It all comes down to consistency. If you aren’t worried about making your cookies heart-healthy, stick margarine will give the right texture and taste that is more comparable to butter.

If you want to eliminate trans fats entirely, use a jar of margarine with a greater fat content.

Other Butter Alternatives for Cookies

If you wish to replace the butter but don’t have margarine (or don’t like it), there are several butter replacements in cookies. I’ll simply mention a few below to assist you out in a situation.

No Butter or Substitute

What? Is there no butter? Yup. Some cookie recipes call for no butter, so you don’t even have to think about substituting it. The outcome will be a less luxurious and crumblier cookie, but it will still taste delicious (particularly if you add more chocolate chips).

Olive Oil

Individuals who want to avoid butter might try olive oil and all of its excellent health benefits. You’ll like the fact that you’re utilizing something healthy while still making a delicious cookie. Expect a little less chewiness at the end. Utilize a 3:4 ratio.

Mashed Avocado or Banana

Avocados and bananas offer several health advantages, making them both great butter substitutes in cookies. Not only that, but they are rich in moisture and will provide the proper consistency for your batter. Just keep in mind that the cookies may be puffier than usual.


You may now confidently use margarine as a substitute for butter in your cookie recipe. But hold on! You are still interested in learning more. Fellow bakers, I’m here to educate you. For additional information, see these frequently asked questions.

What is the difference between using butter and margarine in cookies?

There isn’t much of a difference. Cookies made with butter, on the other hand, tend to be more crumbly, chewy, and flavorful. Margarine has a nice taste, but the texture will be somewhat odd since the cookies spread more than butter, resulting in crisper edges.

What makes cookies softer butter or margarine?

When it comes to making cookies softer, shortening is the way to go. You may use shortening in place of butter (or margarine) at a 1:1 ratio.

Can I use margarine instead of unsalted butter?

Yes, you can simply substitute margarine for unsalted butter in the same way that you would ordinary butter. When substituting margarine for conventional salted butter, you may need to add a pinch of salt.

What can I use in cookies instead of butter?

There are several butter replacements for cookies. I mentioned a few above: olive oil, mashed avocado, banana, and skipping it entirely. You may also use applesauce, coconut oil, peanut butter, shortening, Greek yogurt, and a variety of other ingredients.

What brand of margarine is best for baking?

When it comes to the best margarine for baking, certain products outperform others. The aim is to develop a stick margarine with more fat than the competitors. Earth Balance Buttery Sticks and Land O Lakes Margarine Sticks, for example, are also excellent choices.

Is margarine better than butter?

Yes, in terms of health, margarine is superior than butter. It does not, however, outperform butter in the baking sector. Simply said, butter enhances the tastes in baking and cooking. When contrasted to margarine, it also develops preferred textures.

Final Words

You may simply substitute margarine for butter in your cookie recipe. Simply look for margarine with a greater fat percentage, such as most stick margarine. Keep in mind that margarine cookies are more easily burned since they spread thinner, so keep an eye on them while baking.

Do you prefer butter or margarine for baking? When making cookies, what sort of margarine do you use? Please leave a comment so that we can test it out!


What happens when you use margarine instead of butter in cookies?

Margarine, which has more water and less fat, may result in thin cookies that spread out and burn when baking. For frying, butter is also a preferable option.

Is it better to bake cookies with margarine or butter?

Cakes produced with margarine are denser and lighter in color, but cakes made with butter have a more buttery flavor but are less soft. Butter-based cookie recipes are more caramelized in color and crisper around the edges; margarine-based cookies are chewy but lack the same taste punch.

Does margarine make cookies taste different?

Considerations When Baking Using Margarine and Butter

In terms of flavor, baked products produced with butter have much more flavor than baked goods made with margarine.

Does margarine make good cookies?

However, just because your baked products have a distinct flavor doesn’t imply they’re any less delicious! If you get the appropriate type, margarine may be a nutritious and pleasant substitute for butter. You’ll be able to make wonderful margarine cookies in no time if you practice enough.

Does margarine make cookies cakey?

Remember that the melting points of margarine and butter are quite different, thus the cookie with butter will be flatter. Margarine gives the cookie a cake-like texture.

Does more butter make cookies softer?

More moisture in the form of more butter, egg yolks, or brown sugar added to your dough can make your cookies even softer.

What happens to cookies when you use less butter?

Using too little butter will not destroy your cookies, and they will still be delicious, but it will make them light. These cookies were the most identical to the batch with too much egg. These just blew out differently – they had a muffin top.

What can I use instead of butter in cookies?

The following items, in general, perform well as butter substitutes in cakes, muffins, cookies, brownies, and quick breads:
Applesauce. Applesauce decreases the calorie and fat content of baked foods substantially.
Bananas mashed.
Yogurt from Greece.
Butters made from nuts.
Purée of pumpkin.

Why do homemade cookies taste different?

The ingredients you used might be the problem; adding different sugars, melted butter, baking powder, or baking soda can change the texture and flavor of a cookie. We’ve broken down the six elements that impact your cookies to help you make a consistently good batch time and time again.

Why are butter cookies not crispy?

Adjust the baking time to produce the desired cookie texture. A bit less time results in chewier cookies, whereas a little more time results in crispier cookies. Remove the cookies from the oven when they are still slightly underbaked if you like softer cookies. Always check for doneness after the shortest amount of baking time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top