For baking, cane sugar vs. granulated sugar

For baking, cane sugar vs. granulated sugar

Rate this post

Practically every baked item has sugar in the recipe. However, there are numerous types of baking sugar, such as granulated and cane sugar. What is the distinction? Although they differ slightly, cane and granulated sugar can be used interchangeably in baking.

Hi! My name is Shea, and I like sugar, so it’s no surprise that I adore baking as well; the two go hand in hand! I’ve experimented with various sugars throughout the years to see what the results might be. I discovered that cane and granulated sugar were practically the same, and I’m here to tell you about it.

It does not have to be difficult to get the proper sugar for your recipe. If you just have granulated or cane sugar on hand, you’ll have a fantastic, sweet ending. Yet, knowing the distinction between the two is still useful.

Let’s speak about sugar, sweets, sugars!

Cane Sugar vs. Granulated Sugar for Baking

When a recipe asks for sugar, it might refer to either cane sugar or granulated sugar. When it comes to baking, both may be used interchangeably. Some items, such as syrups, have more stringent sugar requirements.

But we’re simply here to talk about cane sugar vs. granulated sugar for baking, in which case you can use either.

Cane sugar and granulated sugar may be used interchangeably in any baking recipes, such as cookies, muffins, and cakes. Since each form of sugar originates from the same plant and contains the same molecules of sucrose, there is no discernible difference.

Yet, this does not imply that cane sugar and granulated sugar are completely interchangeable. There are a few significant distinctions between the two. Let us investigate more.

Granulated Sugar

Granulated sugar is the most prevalent variety of sugar found in American kitchens. It is also known as white sugar.

This sugar is made from sugar cane or sugar beets. It is extremely processed and has no natural molasses. This super-fine sugar will not cake together if stored correctly. Since the sugar must be metered for excellent results, it is good for baking.

Another reason for its popularity is that it does not alter the look of baked items (or anything else, for that matter). Since the white coloring blends nicely with any recipe, it is preferred over other types of sugars.

Cane Sugar

Cane sugar, on the other hand, is less refined and is derived entirely from sugar cane. When it is little processed, it retains more sweetness than granulated sugar. It has greater taste depth on its own, but when cooked, you can’t detect the difference.

The most significant disadvantage of utilizing cane sugar or granulated sugar is that it can change the look of your baked products. Molasses has a deeper hue since it is not completely refined from cane sugar. This may result in different baked items, such as a deeper tint of cookie.

Everything is the same in terms of flavor. Thus, if you don’t mind your baked items being a little darker than they should be, you may simply substitute cane sugar for granulated sugar.

Which Sugar is Best for Baking?

When it comes to details, granulated sugar is the superior choice for baking. This is due to the fact that it is a very fine white sugar that can be measured and used in any recipe without affecting the result.

Cane sugar may be substituted for granulated sugar. The only thing to keep in mind is that your finished product may seem somewhat darker. Some recipes, such as double chocolate cookies, will be unaffected, although sugar cookies may.


Granulated and cane sugar are both great baking sugars. Continue reading if you have any remaining queries concerning this subject. Some of the most often asked questions concerning cane vs. granulated sugar in baking are answered here.

Is cane sugar healthier than white sugar?

Both sugars are unhealthy, but cane sugar is somewhat better since it maintains more of the fiber content.

What is the best sugar free substitute for baking?

Honey, maple syrup, stevia, and agave are some of the greatest sugar-free baking replacements. Each has advantages and disadvantages. Agave, for example, may affect the taste and texture. Honey is a sticky substance that might be tough to deal with.

Does caster sugar measure the same as granulated sugar?

Theoretically, yes, but since caster sugar is finer, it takes up less volume than granulated sugar. Nevertheless, using the same quantity as granulated sugar will result in more sweeter baked items.

Final Thoughts

In baking, granulated sugar and cane sugar can be used interchangeably, though cane sugar may produce a slightly darker result.

Do you bake using granulated or cane sugar?


Can you use cane sugar instead of granulated sugar for baking?

You absolutely can, and the effects are fantastic. Since it retains some of the molasses taste that is processed out of granulated sugar, C&H® Organic Cane Sugar adds a richer flavor to baked products. It also has a natural blond tint that may be used to color cookies and pastries.

Which sugar is best for baking?

Granulated sugar, often known as white sugar or table sugar, is the most commonly used sugar in baking and cooking. Granulated sugar has a white hue, is highly refined, and has a fine texture. Because of their propensity to dissolve quickly into a liquid or batter, finely powdered sugars are useful for baking.

Does cane sugar bake the same as granulated?

White cane sugar can be used in any recipe that asks for white granulated sugar. They perform almost equally in cooking and baking.

Does cane sugar taste the same as granulated?

When tasted pure, several tasters thought that cane sugar had somewhat greater depth of flavor than normal granulated sugar, although the sugars tasted relatively similar overall.

How do I substitute cane sugar for granulated sugar?

Cane sugar, also known as sugar beet sugar, is made entirely from sugarcane and is lightly processed. Since the molasses has not been refined out, it has a somewhat bigger grain and a deeper hue. Cane sugar may be used in the same manner as granulated sugar is. Unlike highly refined granulated sugar, which may be derived from sugarcane,

Does the type of sugar matter in baking?

Curiously, you might use less of a fructose-containing sweetener, such as honey, to minimize the calorie intake while maintaining the same sweetness level. The chemical structure of various kinds of sugars, on the other hand, will have a considerable influence on the quality of baked goods.

What is the rule of sugar in baking?

Sugar quickly bonds to water, which fulfills two major goals. 1) It retains moisture, preventing your baked products from drying out; and 2) It prevents gluten formation, making your cookies, cakes, and sweet breads softer. Variations in sugar kind will result in various results here.

What is the most used sugar in the bake shop?

The most prevalent kind of sugar is refined granulated sugar.

What sugar is best for moist cake?

Brown sugar is inherently moister than white sugar, resulting in a softer, more moist product. It also frequently darkens the color of your merchandise.

How do different types of sugar affect baking?

Granulated sugar makes baked items crisper, while brown sugar adds chewiness and a moister texture. Using powdered sugar instead of granulated sugar: This replacement should be limited to forgiving baked products such as cookies, brownies, bars, muffins, and quick breads.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top