How to Fix Crumbly Cookie Dough

How to Fix Crumbly Cookie Dough

Rate this post

Baking cookies may be a lot of fun. It might also become a perplexing nightmare. If you followed the recipe exactly and still have crumbly cookie dough that won’t budge, you probably didn’t add enough liquid or oil. Cookie dough, too, needs a brief rest from time to time.

Hello there! My name is Shea, and I am a total cookie junkie. Cookies were one of the first things I learnt to make when I was around ten years old, and they are still one of my favorites. I adore them all, from the traditional chocolate chip to the more exotic persimmon or cranberry.

Don’t panic if you have crumbly cookie dough; it’s not the end of the world. In fact, crumbly cookie dough is one of the simplest cookie repairs. Continue reading to learn how to cure flaky cookie dough.

Whos ready to whip up a batch of cookies?

How to Fix Crumbly Cookie Dough: Problems and Solutions

How to Fix Crumbly Cookie Dough

Crumbly cookie dough is rather frequent and so offers simple fixes. The objective is to determine what went wrong and go from there. The top four reasons why your cookie dough is cracking and how to correct it quickly are listed below.

1. Not Enough Liquid

It makes no difference whether cookie dough recipe you use. It will need a liquid (remember, eggs are considered a liquid for baking cookies!). If you don’t use enough liquid or leave it out entirely, your cookie dough will be crumbly and dry.

What is the answer? It’s rather straightforward. Pour in the liquid. If you completely forgot about it, you would begin by adding the appropriate quantity of liquid to your cookie dough.

If you previously added the liquid but made a measurement error, start by adding a spoonful of liquid (water, milk, etc.) at a time. Add more milk until the cookie dough is no longer crumbly.

You shouldn’t need to add more than a cup of liquid to get your cookie dough back to the right consistency. If you go beyond that quantity, you may have another problem with your cookie dough.

2. Not Enough Fat

Fat is responsible for the thick, chewy texture of your cookies. Prior to that, it is in charge of greasing your cookie dough so that it may be combined, rolled, and baked. The cookie dough will be crumbly if there isn’t enough fat.

The solution is similar to the solution for insufficient liquid. Add some fat. Use the exact kind of fat that your recipe asked for. Use additional butter if the recipe asks for it. If the recipe asks for oil, use that instead.

But don’t go overboard with the fat. If you use too much fat, your cookies will become a flat, lifeless pancake. However, do not add more than a teaspoon of fat. It may not seem to be much, but it will most likely be enough to mix your cookie dough wonderfully.

3. It’s Overmixed

If you use a mixer instead of your hands, you may unintentionally set your cookie dough up for crumbly failure. When cookie dough is over-mixed, it forms a strong gluten network, making it crumbly and difficult to deal with.

Is your cookie dough just too soft? Then take a break. No, really. Allow your cookie dough to rest at room temperature for up to an hour. Refrigerated storage will cause the cookie dough to dry up.

When you’re ready to roll your cookie dough into balls, stop mixing it. Simply scoop it out, roll it in any way you choose, and set it on a baking sheet.

In the future, attempt to use the mixer less often. Mixers work surprisingly quickly, which means your cookie dough will be overworked sooner than you think. To prevent this disaster, use lower settings and less time.

4. Bad Recipe

If you’re attempting a new cookie recipe and it doesn’t appear to be working, it might be a flawed recipe. A baker may mistakenly list the incorrect ingredients or instructions. When others attempt to imitate it, things go awry.

The greatest approach in this circumstance is to just try out a different dish. To achieve the most exact measures, you should also consider purchasing a food scale.


You now understand why your cookie dough is crumbly, as well as how to correct it. If you still have questions regarding this subject, have a look at the commonly asked questions section below.

How do you add moisture to dry cookie dough?

It might sometimes be as easy as spritzing a little water directly onto the dough. Other times, a teaspoon of liquid is required to make the dough malleable (do not add more than a cup of liquid).

What happens if cookie dough is too dry?

If the cookie batter is too dry, it will not cook properly. Liquid and fat are required to get the right texture and taste in your cookies. When you bake dry cookie dough, you’ll get a glob of components that simply don’t taste right.

Can I add an extra egg to cookie dough?

If you want a chewier texture, add an additional egg to the cookie batter.

How do you fix dry cookies after baking?

You have choices if you have dry cookies after baking. Microwave for 15 seconds in a moist paper towel, or lay a piece of white bread in the cookie jar for 24 hours.

Final Words

A crumbly cookie is a no-no, despite its popularity. It is mostly due to the use of insufficient fluids or fat. Overmixing or using a faulty recipe, on the other hand, might be a problem. Fortunately, some blunders have easy fixes: add, rest, or try a different recipe!

How do you fix crumbly cookie dough?


How do you fix dough that is too crumbly?

In modest quantities, add additional liquid components. Milk, egg yolks or whites, vanilla essence, or even a teaspoon of water may help wet the dough and make the cookies less crumbly. A little amount of liquid, such as milk, may also help your cookies spread in the oven, resulting in a crisper cookie.

How do you fix crunchy cookie dough?

You see, all you need to soften a batch of day-old cookies is a piece of bread. This is a tip I learnt from my mother after she witnessed me turn down a slightly crispy chocolate chipper one too many times (self-proclaimed gooey, chewy cookie fanatic here!).

Why is my cookie dough not sticking together?

Crumbly cookie dough is frequently an indication of too much flour and insufficient binding agent. It is typically a clue that you have over-mixed or used too much of a certain ingredient; just add a tablespoon of water, milk, or soft butter to correct this and bond your dough.

Why are my cookies crumbling apart?

Inadequate fat implies poor texture

A lack of fat may be caused by a faulty recipe, underestimating the amount of fat, or using the incorrect kind of fat (see next advice, below). All of these will result in crumbly cookies. If all else fails, add extra tablespoon or two of [room temperature!] butter to the recipe to see if it helps.

Can you add water to crumbly dough?

If you add too much moisture, the dough will become extremely sticky or tacky. When dealing with dry doughs, you often desire pizza or bagels rather than soft dinner rolls. The secret is to gradually add more milk or water.

What happens if you overmix cookie dough?

7. The dough is overworked. If you over-mix (or lay out) cookie dough, it will absorb too much air, causing it to rise and then fall flat in the oven. Excess gluten development may also arise from overmixing the dough, resulting in thick cookies.

How do you firm up cookie dough?

This might be the reason your dough is so soft. So here’s what you should do: Simply add more flour to the dough in 1 tablespoon increments until it reaches the desired consistency. If you’re not sure what the correct consistency is, cook 1 or 2 cookies on their own and watch how they come out.

How do you make cookie dough firmer?

Another option is to add flour. You don’t want too much, so start with one tablespoon and gradually increase from there. This will aid in the adhesion of your materials. While it may not be as stiff as you want, it will enough for baking.

Can you fix crunchy cookies?

They are being microwaved. Covering your cookies with a moist paper towel and nuking them for a few seconds might soften them up enough to consume.

Should refrigerated cookie dough be brought to room temperature before baking?

Cookie dough should be refrigerated for at least 30 minutes and up to 24 hours as a general rule. More than that, and you won’t detect a difference in the end result. Allow the dough to warm up at room temperature until it’s barely malleable (approximately 5 to 10 minutes).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top