How to Know When Your Cookies Are Done

How to Know When Your Cookies Are Done

Rate this post

Great! You created a new batch of delectable cookies, only to discover that the bottoms are entirely scorched or the centre is still ooey-gooey. What should I do now? Understanding when your cookies are done is essential for making it into the cookie-baking hall of fame. But how exactly?

There are several methods for determining when your cookies are done. First, do a visual inspection. The edges of the cookie should be golden brown, and there should be no visible shine.

Tap the borders as well. They are finished if there is no indent. Finally, use a toothpick to verify the consistency.

Hi! My name is Shea, and I like making cookies. I’m always baking something new, whether it’s sugar cookies for a holiday or peanut butter and chocolate chip treats for my cookie-obsessed family.

Let’s discuss how to tell when your cookies are done!

How To Tell if Cookies Are Done: Six Ways

Did you know there are eight different methods to determine whether your cookies are done? With so many approaches available, you can be certain that your cookies are ready to be removed from the oven.

Keep in mind that depending on the kind of cookie, some approaches work better than others. A dark double chocolate cookie, for example, may be more difficult to identify when done visually than a light biscuit, such as shortbread.

1. Visual: Golden Brown Edges

This visual inspection may be used while creating a batch of light cookies. Just glance at the borders of your cookies to do so. Do they have a golden brown color to them? They are most likely finished. Remove them from the oven before the wonderful golden texture burns and becomes unappealing!

2. Visual: Cracked Top

Tops may be used to calculate cookie recipes using little quantities of flour, such as Fudge Ecstasies. After these cookies are finished baking, the top will have a broken open look.

3. Visual: No Sheen

Have you ever peeked at a batch of cookies as they were baking? It starts off as a ball of cookie dough, then flattens and becomes glossy. This means the cookie dough is melting and will soon be transformed into a delicious batch of cookies!

With this in mind, you can determine whether your cookies are done by looking for shine. If your cookies are still glossy and gooey, they aren’t finished. They’ll be ready to travel after they’ve lost their luster and have a more firm structure.

4. Visual: Golden Brown Bottoms

Looking at the bottoms of the cookies is another fast and simple technique to check for doneness. (This is my preferred method of determining when my cookies are done. That is, in my view, a fail-safe method of checking them.)

Just put on an oven mitt and lift the cookie sheet halfway out. Next, using a spatula, carefully lift one of the cookies. When the bottoms are golden brown and firm, remove them from the oven.

I prefer to inspect at least three cookies, one on each side and one in the center. Instead of rotating the pan and cooking for a few more minutes, I know that all of the cookies are done.

5. Physical: Firm Edges

You can’t depend on visual signals while preparing dark cookies, such as these delectable dark chocolate delicacies. The physical path is the superior alternative. Using this strategy, you will once again concentrate on the edges.

Carefully poke one of your biscuits on the side. If the cookie remains firm, it has finished cooking. If it indents or collapses inwards, continue baking for a few more minutes.

6. Last Option: Toothpick Test

Are your cookies ready to chill after baking? If you’re still hesitant, try the tried-and-true approach of using a toothpick. Just insert a toothpick into the middle of your cookie and remove it. They’re not done if the batter is gooey. If it is clean, they are ready to chill.

For this test, you may alternatively utilize a fork. To be honest, I nearly always forget to purchase toothpicks at the supermarket, so I have to resort to using a fork instead. Yeah, it creates a few extra indentations, but that’s no big deal since the cookies are still 110% delicious!


You’re one step closer to cookie perfection! If you want to understand more about this fascinating subject, read on for some commonly asked questions.

Should cookies be soft when they come out?

Some cookies are fluffier than others, so they may turn out soft. They should not, however, be so soft that they are undercooked. If you like a crisper cookie, bake them for a few minutes longer.

Can cookies be undercooked?

Undercooked cookies are possible. How? Just because they were not cooked long enough in the oven. If you realize that your cookies are undercooked as they cool, just return them to the oven to finish baking.

Do cookies harden as they cool?

As you take the cookie sheet out of the oven, the cookies will continue to bake for another five to ten minutes before being moved to a wire rack. The cookie will solidify during this time.

How long should I bake my cookies?

The best thing to do is stick to your cookie recipe and keep an eye on your cookies while they bake. Nonetheless, most cookies will be done in 8 to 12 minutes when cooked at 350 degrees Fahrenheit.

Final Words

Understanding when to stop baking cookies can help you avoid burned and unpleasant cookie mishaps. When feasible, the best method to verify it visually. Examine the edges and bottoms for golden brown color. You may also use the toothpick technique to assess the stiffness of the edges.

How can you tell when your cookies are finished? Please share your tips in the comments section!


What are three ways to tell if your cookies are done?

Here are some tips from recipes on how to detect whether your cookies are done:
Time (they’ll be done in 10-13 minutes)
They no longer have a “glossy finish.”
At the margins, they will be “cracked” or “golden brown.”
Mar 6, 2021

Can cookies be slightly undercooked?

Cookies that are slightly underbaked are chewier, but you don’t want to wind up with raw cookie dough. To avoid this, Southern Living suggests chilling your cookies directly on the baking sheet rather than on a separate cooling rack.

Should cookies be hard or soft when they come out?

Tendering Center

The cookies should be golden brown around the edges but soft in the middle after approximately 10 minutes. If you leave the cookies on the heated baking sheet for one or two minutes before transferring them to a cooling rack, they will continue to cook somewhat.

How do you tell if cookies are undercooked inside?

Light-colored cookies with black speckles usually indicate that they are underbaked. Put the stone back in the oven for a few minutes more, and they should finish baking.

What is the golden rule in baking cookies?

“My golden guideline for baking is to start chilly and finish hot,” she says. The culinary and lifestyle expert claims that grating frozen butter with a box grater yields perfectly sized chunks. “You won’t have any trouble getting the most gorgeous flakiness out of it — in biscuits, scones, pie crusts, and other laminated doughs.”

Do cookies harden as they cool?

When your cookies come out of the oven, the activity doesn’t stop. The liquified sugars cool and solidify, giving crisp bottoms and edges, while the air within cools, somewhat deflating the biscuit.

What does an underbaked cookie look like?

To begin, examine the color of the cookie; uncooked cookies may frequently seem lighter than fully cooked cookies. Also, the texture of the cookie should be firm and somewhat crisp on the exterior while being slightly mushy in the inside. The cookie is most certainly undercooked if it is fully soft and doughy.

Why are my cookies still gooey in the middle?

Warm cookie dough or too much butter can cause the cookies to spread too much, causing them to bake fast on the exterior but stay raw in the inside. Next time, chill your cookies in the refrigerator for 10 minutes before baking. If the issue continues, reduce the amount of butter used.

Why are my cookies still doughy inside?

Overly Doughy

Underbaking, which prevents adequate moisture from evaporating, may result in doughy cookies. Reduce the oven temperature and extend the baking time if the edges of your cookies are completely cooked but the middle is still too doughy.

Is it better to overcook or undercook cookies?

Remove the cookie sheet from the oven when the cookies are just set: underbaking is preferable than overbaking. Making cookies fast in a hot oven – at 375 degrees F rather than a lower temperature – will result in soft cookies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top