People are always worried about reheating their pizza. The iconic mushy, clearly warmed pizza is tedious and unappealing. These concerns are eliminated by using a toaster oven. Pizza comes out as good as new after a few minutes at 350F in the toaster oven.

Hello there! My name is Shea, and I am a major pizza enthusiast. But reheating has always been my weakness. I despise having to wait for the oven to heat up for a single slice. That is why, for better outcomes, I have resorted to other gadgets such as my toaster oven.

I welcome you to this essay, pizza lovers who are sick and weary of subpar reheated pizza. We’re going to win the game of reheated pizza with a single appliance: the toaster oven.

Whos ready for some magnificent reheated pizza?

How to Reheat Pizza in Toaster Oven

I like reheating pizza in a toaster oven for two reasons. One, it is quite simple. Two, unlike an oven, it does not heat the whole home. I mean, seriously? Crispy, perfectly cooked pizza without the sacrifice of sweat? That’ll do any day.

To prepare reheated pizza in a toaster oven, you’ll obviously need a good toaster oven. (As an aside, did Sonja Morgan ever create her toaster oven? We had been waiting.)

You’ll also need some pizza. However, unless you have a large-capacity toaster oven, you will be restricted to a single slice. But isn’t that fine? Who wants to share leftover pizza slices in the first place? (Not me. Yes, I am self-centered.)

Now that you have your two items lets get cookin.

1. Preheat Toaster Oven to 400F

The first step is to have your toaster oven ready. Because, honestly, do I need to explain it? Putting frozen pizza in a chilly toaster oven isn’t going to help. Please bear with us. I swear it won’t take that long!

2. Spritz the Pizza with Water

Um? I understand. It doesn’t sound very enticing. Don’t worry, it won’t make your pizza wet! A little spritz with water will aid in the retention of moisture. The end result? Who doesn’t want a little extra gooeyness?

3. Slide Pizza Inside and Wait

This will be the most difficult aspect of reheating pizza in a toaster oven. Why? Because all you have to do is stand there and watch your pizza return to its ooey-gooey glory. And you can’t take it out until it’s done, which should only take around five minutes.

*Cooking time will vary according to the amount of pizza slices.

4. Remove from Toaster Oven

When the cheese has achieved a perfectly melted consistency, slide the pizza out. Take caution since it will be really hot. Yum! Use a spatula to avoid burning yourself or damaging your pizza. Wear an oven mitt if you’re using a toaster oven pan.

5. Cool and Enjoy

Let’s face it, you don’t have to chill it. But be warned: if you don’t let it cool, it will burn your mouth and tongue. Is it worthwhile? Maybe. But don’t blame me if you end up with a sore mouth!

It is always preferable to wait a few minutes before indulging. Could you please make yourself a drink of cool soda while you wait? Why not crack up a can of beer? Why not just use water and ice cubes?

Pro Tip: Use the Reheat Function

If you have a toaster oven with a reheat feature, disregard everything I mentioned and just utilize the reheat option. As you would expect, the reheat option is particularly intended for warming items like pizza to perfection.

FAQs

Isn’t it easy to heat up pizza in the toaster oven? Don’t worry if you still have any queries. I gathered some of the most often asked questions regarding this issue on the internet, and I’m here to answer them for you. Let’s get started, people.

How long do you reheat pizza in a toaster oven?

How long depends on how many pieces you’re reheating and how crispy you want your slices. However, it usually takes around five minutes. (A single slice may only need three minutes, while four slices may require up to eight.) Keep an eye out for it!

What is the best temperature to reheat pizza in a toaster oven?

Some sources recommend 350F, while others recommend 425F. That’s why I went with 400 degrees Fahrenheit in the center. This is a preferable alternative since it will get perfectly crispy with the cheese melted but not scorched.

What is the best way to reheat pizza in the oven?

If you’re using a conventional oven instead of a toaster oven, I suggest heating the pan in the oven (with parchment paper or aluminum foil on top) until it reaches 400F. Then, set your pizza pieces on top and cook for approximately five minutes, or until the texture is to your liking.

How do you reheat pizza so it’s crispy?

To obtain the best crispiness, use a toaster oven, conventional oven, or air fryer. The secret is to cook it for a little bit longer. So, after the cheese has melted and the dish has finished cooking, just keep it in for another 30 seconds to a minute. Make careful it doesn’t get burned!

Final Words

It’s a brilliant idea to reheat pizza in a toaster oven. It’s fast and simple, and it won’t result in a stifling hot home. I suggest cooking at 400 degrees Fahrenheit for around five minutes, but you may vary the duration as needed. Don’t forget to spray the pizza with some water!

Have you ever used a toaster oven to reheat pizza? What were the outcomes? Do you have any toaster oven recommendations? Share your thoughts in the comments box below!