How to Soften Difficult Brownies

How to Soften Difficult Brownies

Rate this post

I’ll admit it: I sometimes want a crispy brownie. Isn’t it strange? The majority of us favor a soft, ultra-chewy chocolaty treat. So sinking your teeth into a tough mess might be disastrous. Fortunately, there are several methods for softening those tough infants.

Hi! My name is Shea, and brownies are my undoing. I like making them with various fillings, such as Reese’s Pieces, walnuts, or M&Ms. Indeed, the list goes on and on. With all of my expertise, I discovered the best techniques for softening a hard brownie.

You don’t have to put up with hard brownies. Whether you need them softened tomorrow or today, I have the solution. There are several techniques to soften hard brownies listed below. They’re all really easy, so don’t be concerned about not having any particular equipment.

Who’s up for some soft, gooey brownies?

How to Soften Hard Brownies

As I previously said, there are several alternatives for softening brownies. You will undoubtedly discover a way that works for you and your scenario. Let’s get started, shall we?

1. Quick and Easy – Microwave

If you found this post, I’m guessing you’re craving a softened brownie right now. Are I correct, or am I correct? Tossing a softened, chewy, and delicious brownie into your handy microwave is the quickest method.

A few seconds will enough. You really don’t want to overcook your brownie in the microwave. The texture gets strange. To prevent another brownie blunder, just microwave your brownie for five to 10 seconds, depending on the power of your microwave.

A fast tip: wrap the brownie in a moist paper towel. This will help you attain maximum softness by the time your microwave beeps.

2. Less Fast, Yet Still Convenient – Oven

I like using the oven for a variety of purposes, but cooking food is not one of them. Nevertheless, if you want a succulent, moist, and completely soft brownie overflowing with chocolate, the few additional minutes are well worth it.

Preheat the oven to 300 degrees Fahrenheit to soften your brownie. After hot, add the brownies and cook for four to six minutes. Inspect them often to ensure they are not overdone. An overdone brownie is a chewy, hard, and unappealing treat.

3. Slow But Reliable – White Bread

If you ever find yourself in a position when you don’t need a soft brownie right away, you can always use this low-and-slow approach. You’ll need a couple slices of white bread and an airtight container to pull off the white bread trick.

In the bottom of the container, place a slice of white bread. After that, add the brownies. Then top with another slice of white bread.

Honestly, it works, even though it seems entirely out of the ordinary and bizarre. For the white bread and brownie contraption to work, it must be kept in the container for at least a day.

How to Prevent Hard Brownies

I am a great believer in averting disasters before they occur, and this includes brownies. Why bother making hard, unappealing brownies in the first place? There are a few basic strategies you may use to avoid having hard and unforgivable brownies.

1. Don’t Put Them in the Refrigerator

Many people attempt to keep their brownies fresher by storing them in the refrigerator. Don’t feel embarrassed; I used to do that as well. But I finally got it when every time I scooped a brownie out of the container, they were as hard as a rock.

The refrigerator will draw moisture out of the baked goods, leaving you with little more than a hard shell of what was once an ooey-gooey and delightful brownie.

So, what are your options? As long as they are securely packed, you may leave them on the counter for up to four days. You don’t believe you can eat them that quickly? For one thing, I admire your restraint. Second, put them in the freezer.

Yes, brownies may be stored in the freezer for up to four months. They must, however, be securely wrapped and fastened to prevent freezer burn. Let them to completely thaw before eating, and they should be as good as new.

2. Don’t Overbake

Brownies that are overbaked? I shudder at the prospect. Overbaking is a sure-fire way to wind up with hard, unappealing brownies. It’s advisable to check on your brownies a few minutes before they’re scheduled to be done.

Examine the scenario. Do crumbs fall out when you inspect the center? You want a little crumbly texture. If there are none and the pick is completely clean, they are overdone.

3. Don’t Cut While Warm

If you’re like me, you don’t want to wait for baked products to cool before jumping in. But try to maintain some control. Cutting into heated brownies might make them hard and unappealing. Hence, before cutting the brownies, allow them to cool completely.


We were all determined to figure out how to soften hard brownies and prevent the situation in the first place. Continue reading if you have any remaining queries about this subject. These are some of the most often requested questions from bakers.

Why are my brownies rock hard?

It’s possible that your brownies were improperly kept. If they’re rock hard right out of the oven, you probably didn’t add enough moist ingredients to the batter. Next time, double-check the ingredients and measurements.

What can I do with overcooked brownies?

Overcooked brownies do not have to be thrown out. Overcooked brownies are a delicious addition to milkshakes. They may also be chopped and used as a garnish. If you’re feeling very inventive, pulse them in a food processor and incorporate them into meals.

How do you moisten brownie batter?

Is your brownie batter too thick and dry? A spoonful or two of milk is an easy remedy. Milk will give moisture as well as a little amount of fat, resulting in a moist, delectable brownie. Pour in some chocolate milk for extra chocolaty pleasure!

How do you make brownies not overcooked?

Rotating the pan midway through baking is an easy method to prevent brownies from overcooking. Check on your brownies a few minutes before they’re meant to be done. Crumbles should be clinging to the pick. Absolutely clean is excessive.

Final Thoughts

Hard brownies aren’t ideal, but you now know how to make them. The fastest method is to pop it in the microwave for a few seconds. You may alternatively choose a slower approach, such as baking white bread in the oven or overnight. Therefore, it is preferable to avoid it from the start!

Have you ever gotten hard brownies? What steps did you take to repair them? Please share your experiences in the comments section!


How do you fix hard dry brownies?

Soften in the microwave

Wrap each brownie slice in a wet paper towel to keep it moist in the microwave. Put in the microwave for approximately 5 seconds on medium. Assess the softness of the brownies and repeat for 5 seconds if required.

What causes brownies to harden?

Follow the recipe properly to produce a delicate texture and rich taste. Overcooking is often caused by an improper oven temperature, causing these sweet delicacies to harden around the edges. Warm brownies can make your day much better.

What to do with over cooked brownies?

What to Do With Overcooked Brownies
Make some milkshakes. Every milkshake would be improved by the addition of brownies.
Prepare Tiramisu…. Brownie Crumbs…. Freeze it for later.
Brownie Trifle…. Pudding Prepared With Brownies…. Deep-Fried Brownie Bites…. Brownie Truffles.
More to come…

How do you keep brownies soft and chewy?

Wrap brownies snugly in plastic wrap or foil and store them at room temperature in an airtight container, such as a covered tray or Tupperware container. This will keep your brownies fresh and keep any pollutants out.

How do you add moisture to brownies?

Canola Oil and Eggs – Since brownie mixes often ask for oil and eggs, these are two common components for boxed brownies. Both offer moisture and aid in the creation of a fudgy brownie.

What do overcooked brownies look like?

Chocolate Brownies

This indicates that it is overdone, dry, and crumbly. Instead, you want to see some brown crumbs on the toothpick. The crumbs should be moist but not soggy. If the toothpick comes out with wet, goopy batter stuck to it, the cake need longer baking time.

Will brownies harden when they cool?

It is crucial to remember that your brownies will thicken up as they cool, but they will not solidify until cooled in the refrigerator or freezer. At room temperature, your brownies should be fudgy, firm, and melt-in-your-mouth.

Do brownies harden when you take them out?

Is it going to harden? Allowing your brownies to cool on their own will not cause them to harden. Allowing the brownies to cool to room temperature is the best way to get the correct hard texture that melts in your mouth.

Can you put brownies back in the oven?

Cover the brownies with tin foil before returning them to the oven. This procedure keeps the edges from browning or hardening more while also trapping heat in the pan. You could get decent results if you microwave them on a nonstick pan and leave them slightly underdone.

Can you soften overcooked brownies?

You may soften the brownies by baking them again for a few minutes or microwaving them for a few seconds. You may also add some simple syrup or milk to soften them. Put the brownies on a slice of bread or a piece of parchment paper. These approaches have also been tried and tested and work well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top