How to Store Cookies and Keep Them Fresh

How to Store Cookies and Keep Them Fresh

Rate this post

Most cookie recipes provide a huge number of cookies, which is fantastic. What isn’t so fantastic is keeping them wrong and resulting in stale cookies. For up to two weeks, keeping at room temperature is the best choice. If not, store it in the freezer.

Hello there! My name is Shea, and one of the first things I learnt to make was cookies. I now bake cookies ranging from simple chocolate chip to more complex persimmon and pumpkin tastes.

Do you want to know how to preserve cookies to keep them fresh? Then you’ve arrived to the correct location. This article will show you how to store cookies properly, whether you like soft and chewy cookies or want a crisper choice.

Lets store some cookies!

How to Store Cookies and Keep Them Fresh

How to Store Cookies and Keep Them Fresh

If you’re wondering how to keep cookies, let me start by stating it’s simple! All you need to understand is that soft and crunchy cookies are not the same thing. Something different is also required when freezing cookies. Let’s get started.

Storing Cookies At Room Temperature

Whether you’re preparing soft cookies for chewy sweetness or crispy cookies for crunch, keeping them at room temperature is the best choice. Cookies will keep their texture and taste for two weeks if stored at room temperature.

Storing Chewy Cookies

The purpose of chewy cookies is to keep moisture and air out. Otherwise, your cookies will be dry and tasteless. The easiest method to do this is to keep chewy cookies in an airtight container. A sealable freezer bag may also be used, albeit it is less dependable.

Storing Crispy Cookies

Crispy cookies aren’t as fussy. A ventilated container with a little of air within is the best choice for crispy cookies. Crispy biscuits may soon turn mushy and chewy without this pinch of airflow, which is obviously not the intention here.

Consider keeping crunchy cookies in an old-fashioned cookie jar. These containers are intended to let exactly the *right* amount of air inside, preserving the crispness of our cookies.

Quick Tips for Room Temperature Storage

Alternatively, chewy cookies. Follow these easy guidelines for the best results:When it comes to preserving soft and delicate items, there are a few things to bear in mind.

  • Store soft and crunchy items separately. Did you know that your crisp cookies may absorb moisture from the soft cookies, causing the crunchy texture to change? Separately store your cookies to keep them soft or crunchy.
  • Each jar has just one flavor. Making a large batch of cookies? Great! Just don’t keep them together, or the tastes will blend. (Can you image combining a pumpkin cookie with a dark chocolate peppermint cookie? No, thank you).
  • Before storing, make sure they’re completely cool. Regardless of the sort of cookie, make sure it’s completely cool before storing it. Otherwise, you’ll get awful mushy cookies.
  • If feasible, use a single layer. For cookies, a single layer is the ideal option. If you need more layers, spread wax paper between them to keep them from sticking together.
  • Keep perishable cookies in the refrigerator. If you utilize perishable components, avoid storing cookies at room temperature. Instead, store it in the refrigerator for up to five days.

Storing Cookies in the Freezer

If you’ve read any of my earlier storage how-tos, such as How to Store Cupcakes, you’ll note that the refrigerator is constantly mentioned. But we’re going to do things a little differently in this piece. This time, I strongly advise against using the refrigerator.

Why? Because cookies stay far longer at room temperature than other baked items. In fact, if there is nothing perishable in or on top of the cookie, it may survive up to two weeks. You’ll most likely finish the cookies inside that time span.

If you need to preserve anything for more than two weeks, the best choice is to freeze it rather than refrigerate it. This is how you do it.

  1. Check that the cookies have completely cooled. Again, this is very necessary to prevent a soggy cookie disaster.
  2. If possible, line the cookies in a single layer. A single layer of cooking is advised.
  3. Line numerous layers with wax paper. You don’t want your cookies to get glued together. Place a piece of wax paper between each layer of cookies to prevent this.
  4. Cover tightly with a lid or plastic wrap. If you’re going to use a container, be sure it’s airtight and has a lid. If not, carefully cover the cookies in plastic wrap.

Note: You may take cookie storage to the next level by carefully wrapping each cookie in plastic wrap and lining them in single layers. Cookies may be frozen for up to six months with or without this additional step.

When you’re ready to eat the cookies, just defrost them on the counter for approximately an hour before serving. Some folks have even microwaved or baked their cookies to speed up the thawing process.


It’s simple to store cookies and keep them fresh. You just need to know how to preserve them based on their taste and texture. If you’re still thinking about this, have a look at the commonly asked questions below.

How do you keep cookies fresh for 5 days?

Keeping cookies fresh for five days should be a breeze. Soft cookies should be stored in an airtight container or resealable bag. Crispy cookies should be stored in a looser container, such as a cookie jar, or in a resealable bag with the top slightly open to let air within.

Can you Refrigerate cookies to keep them fresh?

I never advocate refrigerating baked anything, even cookies. The refrigerator is notorious for drying out baked goods, whether they be brownies, cupcakes, or cookies. When keeping for more than two weeks, it is best to store at room temperature or in the freezer.

Can I store cookies in Ziploc bags?

You can certainly keep cookies in a Ziploc bag. You may need to use numerous bags to ensure that the cookies are laid out in a single layer. Otherwise, the absence of structure in the baggy might cause them to stay together or crumble into a crumbly mess.

Final Words

For crispy or soft and chewy cookies, room temperature storage is optimal. Ensure that various textures and tastes are kept separately so that they do not mix. When keeping for more than two weeks, use the freezer instead.

How do you preserve and keep your cookies fresh?


Will cookies stay fresh in a Ziploc bag?

Cookies may be stored at room temperature for two to three days. If your lovely cookie jar isn’t airtight (or you don’t know) and you still want to use it to store cookies on the counter, place your cookies in a sealable plastic bag before placing them inside the jar, then zip your cookies in to keep air out.

Where do you store cookies to keep them fresh?

Keep the cookies chilled.

Cookies will keep the longest in a cold, dry spot, such as the back shelf of your cupboard. They may endure anywhere from a few days to a few weeks, depending on the kind. Cookies may also be frozen for up to six months.

Should cookies be kept in the fridge or on the counter?

Unless otherwise specified, do not keep cookies in the refrigerator: the chilly air may dehydrate cookies and make them taste bland. Cookies should be stored at room temperature or frozen, as mentioned above.

How do you keep cookies fresh and crisp?

The Best Way to Keep Cookies Crisp
Allow cookies to cool fully before storing.
Store soft cookies apart from crunchy cookies.
Crispy cookies may be stored in glass containers.
Store in a covered container rather than in plastic bags.
Cookies may be kept crisp by refrigerating them.

How do you store cookies so they don’t get stale?

Place the cookies in an airtight container or zip-top plastic bag if you want to consume them within a few days. A piece of sandwich bread may also be placed inside the container to absorb excess moisture and keep the cookies soft.

Do cookie tins keep cookies fresh?

To begin with, tins hide sunlight, which is vital for maintaining taste in most foods, thus the requirement for home pantries. Furthermore, tins offer no flavor or aroma to cookies. Most importantly, tins reduce air and humidity transfer significantly, preserving the softness or crispiness of your biscuits.

How long do cookies last in airtight container?

Regular handmade cookies may be kept in an airtight container at room temperature for 4-5 days and in the freezer for up to 9 months. However, this is a generality, and various types of cookies have varied responses, so continue reading to learn more about how long cookies last.

How do you wrap cookies in parchment paper?

Parchment is the first option.

Wrap the cookies on parchment paper lengthwise and roll into a tube form. Tape the roll closed. Gently screw the end closed. Cover the white roll with a band of decorative paper (or two!) and fasten with tape.

How long can cookies be stored and retain freshness?

Information. Bakery or handmade cookies may be kept at room temperature for two to three weeks or in the refrigerator for two months. Cookies keep their quality in the freezer for eight to twelve months.

Why should cookies be covered when storing in the refrigerator?

Most handmade cookies will keep their flavor and texture for up to three days. If you leave the cookies out for too long, they can harden or dry out. To protect cookies from becoming stale, wrap them in plastic wrap or store them in an airtight container.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top