Replacement for Brown Sugar in Cookies

Replacement for Brown Sugar in Cookies

Rate this post

Brown sugar is a common component in most cookie recipes due to its deep, rich, and caramel taste. Don’t worry if you don’t have any on hand. There are several possible possibilities, including white sugar (simple or with mix-ins), molasses, honey, and other sugars.

Hello there! My name is Shea, and I have over 10 years of expertise as a self-taught baker. Brown sugar is nearly always in my cupboard, but it hasn’t always been that way (I get lazy and dont want to go shopping sometimes, too). Fortunately, I’ve discovered several excellent options.

If you’re in the mood to make some cookies but don’t have any brown sugar, keep reading. The following is a comprehensive list of the finest brown sugar replacements for cookies.

Let’s start baking!

Brown Sugar Substitute in Cookies

Brown sugar is used in many cookie recipes, but the good news is that it is simple to reproduce. You may discover an alternative that works for you whether you stick to basic components like white sugar and honey or delve into less-traveled possibilities like Muscovado sugar.

White Sugar

White sugar is an excellent substitute for brown sugar. Why? Because practically everyone has access to white sugar. This is particularly true if you want to bake cookies. Let’s face it, most recipes call for a combination of white and brown sugar!

In cookie recipes, white sugar may be used in lieu of brown sugar, cup for cup. It may lack the depth of brown sugar, but in many circumstances, you won’t notice. But, keep in mind that the cookies will be crisper.

Consider adding additional mix-ins to your white sugar to add some richness:

  • A spoonful or two of molasses. White sugar and molasses are two of the greatest substitutes for brown sugar. This is due to the presence of molasses in brown sugar. So, effectively, you’re manufacturing your own light or dark brown sugar.
  • A spoonful of maple syrup. Another feasible alternative is maple syrup. It has a similar taste and feel like molasses.
  • A spoonful of honey. Honey is another easy remedy. It’s a little lighter than maple syrup and molasses, but it works well.

Alternative Sugars

Some people cringe when they hear the name white sugar, and that’s OK. Some individuals cannot use white sugar for health reasons, whether they have high glucose levels or just wish to be healthier overall by using different sugar sources.

Does this describe you? So you’ll be pleased to learn that several different sugars may be substituted for brown sugar. These are a few of our favorites:

  • or a lack of moisture. Sugar made from coconuts. Coconut sugar tastes eerily identical to brown sugar yet contains vitamins, minerals, and fiber. Although it may be used in a 1:1 ratio, a little more fat is suggested to prevent density.
  • Turbinado sugar is a kind of sugar. Raw sugar is a flavorful alternative to turbinado that may also be used in a 1:1 ratio. But, since the granules are bigger and more difficult to combine, you may wish to dissolve it in warm water before adding it to your batter.
  • Sugar made from muscovado. Did you realize that muscovado includes molasses, much like brown sugar? Most cookie recipes call for much too much Muscovado. For the best results, go for light muscovado sugar or use half the quantity.
  • Sugar from palm trees. This sugar, also known as palm date sugar, is offered as a thick paste that must be broken down before being added to cookie dough. But, the taste is fantastic, so it is definitely worth the effort.

Liquid Sweeteners

Employing a liquid sweetener, such as honey or molasses, might be difficult. Yet, if you combine the appropriate ingredients, you will have a fantastic brown sugar alternative in cookies.

So, what’s the big deal with liquid sweeteners? When adding to a cookie recipe, be sure you use a cup for every cup of brown sugar asked for. To prevent a watery, unappealing batter, lower the total liquid.

Fruit Puree

If you haven’t already heard, incorporating fruit puree into cookies (and other baked products) is becoming more trendy. Most people, however, believe that fruit purees should only be used to replace butter. It is not always true.

If you’re in a hurry and need to add additional sweetness to your cookie dough, fruit purees are a great option. But, the kind of fruit you use may have an effect on the overall taste. If you choose apple or banana as your fruit, you could detect a trace of it in your cookies.

Date puree is the greatest substitute for brown sugar in cookies. Date puree has a very rich and toffee-like flavor that tastes similar to brown sugar. Give it a go!


You now understand the finest brown sugar alternative for cookies. If you’re still interested in this subject, have a look at the commonly asked questions below.

Can I replace sugar with brown sugar in cookies?

You certainly can! In cookie recipes, replacing white sugar with brown sugar works like a charm. Note that the taste may have less depth and the cookies may be crisper. (But, is it truly a terrible thing? I’m a huge fan!)

Can you substitute honey for brown sugar in cookies?

Definitely, since their taste characteristics are similar. Since honey is a liquid, the ratio must be reduced to cup per 1 cup of brown sugar. For the greatest outcomes, other liquid elements should be lowered as well.

Is Demerara sugar brown sugar?

Yes, technically. In look and taste, Demerara sugar is comparable to brown sugar. It is, however, a significantly bigger grain than brown sugar. As a result, it is often used as a topping to provide some crunch.

Is golden caster sugar the same as brown sugar?

Although they are somewhat similar, they are not the same thing. Golden caster sugar is refined and has a milder taste than brown sugar. As a result, it may be used as a substitute, but it will not have the necessary taste range.

Final Words

Is there no brown sugar? No worries. To get the task done, use white sugar and liquid sweeteners, or try an alternative sugar like muscovado. When you’re in a panic and need to add flavor and sweetness to your cookies, you can even use fruit purees!

Have you ever baked with one of these brown sugar substitutes? Which one is your personal favorite? Please share your tales and thoughts with us in the comments section!


Is brown sugar necessary in cookies?

Is brown sugar required for cookies? Most chocolate chip cookie recipes call for a combination of brown sugar (for increased moisture and chewiness) and granulated sugar (for a small crisp on the cookie’s edges), although this is not required.

What can I use instead of brown sugar for chocolate chip cookies?

Brown sugar substitutes in chocolate chip cookies

Granulated sugar (white sugar) is a great cup-for-cup substitute for brown sugar. While white sugar does not include molasses, its nutritional properties are fairly comparable to those of brown sugar. Golden sugar is granulated sugar with a molasses taste.

Can I replace brown sugar with white sugar in cookies?

In most baking recipes, brown sugar may be substituted for white sugar in a one-to-one ratio. Thus, instead of one cup white sugar, use one cup brown sugar. While the sweetness level will remain the same, the brown sugar may alter the texture of your baked items.

What can I use instead of brown sugar in cookies?

7 Ingenious Brown Sugar Substitutes
Molasses with white sugar.
Maple syrup with white sugar.
Sugar made from coconuts.
Honey, maple syrup, or agave syrup are all options.
Sugar in its natural state.
Sugar that is white.

Why do chocolate chip cookies need brown sugar?

Brown sugar, on the other hand, is thick and compacts quickly, resulting in fewer air pockets during creaming—less potential to entrap gas, resulting in cookies that rise less and spread more. They remain moist and chewy because less moisture escapes via steam.

Does brown sugar make cookies taste different?

Tip: Using white sugar instead of brown sugar (or vice versa) will not change the sweetness of the cookie, but it will change the texture and color.

How much maple syrup to replace brown sugar?

For every 1 cup of brown sugar, use 4 cups of maple syrup. Another alternative is to use maple syrup instead of brown sugar in recipes that call for it. It is preferable to use a darker maple syrup, such as Grade B, although any maple syrup will suffice. The ratio is 3 in this case.

How much molasses do you add to sugar to make brown sugar?

1 granulated sugar cup (200g)
If you want to produce dark brown sugar, use 2 tablespoons unsulphured molasses instead of 1 tablespoon.
Feb 25, 2021

Can you use honey instead of brown sugar?

Honey may be substituted for white sugar, brown sugar, maple syrup, or corn syrup in any recipe that asks for sugar.

How does white sugar affect cookies differently than brown sugar?

Brown sugar adds moisture to the cookies, and the acidity reacts with the protein in the cookie dough, resulting in tougher cookies, while white sugar melts quicker and spreads the cookies thin (Selasky).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top