What Happens If You Put Too Much Yeast in Bread?

What Happens If You Put Too Much Yeast in Bread?

Rate this post

Yeast is required for bread. There is virtually no way around it. However, if you’re working through a recipe and realize you’ve added much too much yeast, you may worry.

Too much yeast in your bread dough may result in a variety of unpleasant outcomes, such as bread collapsing before, during, or after baking, and loaves smelling and tasting like yeast or alcohol.

Needless to say, you don’t want to over-yeast your bread dough. The good news is that you may be able to repair your dough before baking it. And that is exactly what I am here to educate.

Oh, and by the way! My name is Shea, and I’ve been making various types of bread for the last several years. Of course, I am not perfect, and no one is. I’ve mistakenly over-added one or more ingredients, including yeast.

Today, I’ll explain what occurs when your bread dough has too much yeast and how you might attempt to correct it. The key word here is “try.”

Lets talk about yeast!

What Happens if You Put Too Much Yeast in Bread?

What Happens If You Put Too Much Yeast in Bread?

Most people are aware that bread dough requires yeast, thus it is critical not to leave it out unless you want a flat, thick, and lifeless loaf, which I will presume you do not want.

Yeast is largely responsible for producing carbon dioxide during the resting phase, which ensures that your loaf rises and has the correct texture. However, yeast produces ethanol, lactic acid, and organic acid in the dough, all of which contribute to the overall texture and taste.

So, what happens if you over-yeast your bread dough? The first step is to relax and not punish yourself. Even professionals make errors, believe me.

However, below are some of the possible side effects.

1. Irregular Holes

Connoisseurs of bread often describe it as having a wonderful and lovely open crumb. This is particularly true with Artisan breads. An open crumb is not only a mark of beauty, but it is also what gives bread its light and airy quality.

Is it a crumb with uneven holes? Not only does this bread not appear appealing, but it also lacks the necessary texture.

2. Paleness

Okay, so pale bread isn’t the worst thing ever. However, it lacks both appearance and taste. Sure, pale bread is safe to eat, but it lacks the delicious flavor of bread with a lovely caramelized crust.

3. Collapsing

Too much yeast causes the necessary gasses to be released before the bread dough is ready to expand. The end result? Bread that crumbles. This may happen before, during, or after baking, but it is most likely to happen during scoring the bread.

4. Lack of Flavor and Scent

Have you ever cooked bread in your home? The aroma is wonderful. There is nothing quite like the aroma of freshly made bread. What about the flavor? Put it out of your mind. Once you’ve made your own bread, you’ll never go back to store-bought loaves.

However, if you add too much yeast, you will lose the wonderful aroma and taste. Simply said, too much yeast inhibits the formation of flavor and fragrance, resulting in a bland loaf.

5. Alcohol/Yeast Taste and Smell

yeast. While it is possible to eat bread that smells like alcohol, it is not the most delightful experience, particularly if you are not a huge beer enthusiast.If your yeasty bread dough does develop an aroma or taste, it will most likely be comparable to alcohol.

6. Undesirably Massive Oven Spring

The spring or rise that happens immediately after inserting the bread dough in the oven is referred to as oven spring. This is something you desire to happen.

However, too much of anything is harmful. When you add too much yeast, you may get a tremendous oven spring, which causes the dough to adhere to the edges and top of the oven, resulting in a huge and undesired mess.

What to Do if You Add Too Much Yeast to Bread Dough

Obviously, too much yeast in your bread dough is not ideal. The good news is that there are a few things you can do to attempt to salvage it. Your bread may not turn out perfectly, but it will not go to waste.

Here are a few methods you can try.

1. Slow Down Fermentation

Fermentation is as important as yeast in bread-making. While I normally recommend letting your bread rise at room temperature, bread with too much yeast need a colder environment to ferment, such as the refrigerator.

Cooling the temperature slows the generation of gas, which helps to prevent overproduction, which may result in a collapsed loaf. So, put the bread dough in the fridge for a few hours to ferment.

2. Underproof it Slightly

Over-proofing and under-proofing are also not something I normally suggest. However, desperate times need extreme methods.

If you know you’ve over-yeasted your dough, place it in the oven somewhat under-proofed. This may prevent a large oven spring (and subsequent gigantic mess). When you pierce under-proofed bread, it will bounce back pretty fast.

3. Add Salt to the Dough

The kryptonite of yeast is salt. So go ahead and season your bread dough with another pinch of salt. This may assist in controlling the yeast’s production of gasses and acids, perhaps protecting your bread from dangers such as collapse and a lack of taste and aroma.

4. Don’t Cut Before Baking

While cutting is a common part of the bread-making process, it is best avoided if you have used too much yeast. Again, this is merely to keep the loaf from collapsing. Simply bake your uncut bread dough and cross your fingers!


Needless to say, you must use extreme caution when adding yeast to your bread dough. Don’t go overboard! If you want to understand more about this subject, I’ve included a few commonly asked questions that you may find interesting.

What happens if you double the yeast in a bread recipe?

Doubling the yeast in your bread recipe could help it rise quicker or fluffier and lighter, but this is not the case. As previously stated, too much yeast has harmful implications.

How much yeast do I use for 3 cups of flour?

A teaspoon per cup of flour is the standard recommended. Keeping this in mind, you should use 1 teaspoon of yeast for every three cups of flour. However, it is always preferable to stick to the bread recipe you are using, since various varieties of bread need different quantities.

What is the difference between active dry yeast and instant yeast?

Active yeast must be activated before use, while instant yeast is ready to use right away. In bread recipes, they may be used interchangeably. However, bear in mind that the active yeast must be activated in warm water with a pinch of sugar for a few minutes before use.

Too Much Yeast is a Definite No-No for Bread-Baking

When preparing bread, take special care not to use too much yeast. It may not only cause your bread to collapse, but it can also ruin the taste, fragrance, and general texture.

Did you use too much yeast? Save it by fermenting it in the fridge, slightly underproofing it, and not cutting it before baking.

Have you ever made bread dough with too much yeast? What was the end result? How did you resolve it? Please share your experiences and ideas with us!


What happens if you let yeast rise too much?

If the dough does not bounce back at all, it has most certainly been over-proofed. When the dough rises too much before baking, it will collapse rather than rise under the oven’s heat, resulting in an uneven and jagged crumb.

Does too much yeast make bread sour?

If your bread has a sour, yeasty flavor and smells like alcohol, you employed too much yeast.Alternatively, you might use old yeast or creamed fresh yeast with sugar.

Will bread rise more if I add more yeast?

Yeast converts the carbohydrates and sugars in wheat to carbon dioxide gas, inflating air bubbles in the bread and causing it to rise. The bread rises more and more as the yeast multiplies and produces more carbon dioxide.

How much yeast do I use for 4 cups of flour?

4 teaspoons) may increase 4 cups of flour.What Is a Common Yeast-to-Flour Ratio? 1 packet dry yeast (2 and 1)

How do I know if I put too much yeast?

By releasing gas before the flour is ready to expand, too much yeast may cause the dough to flatten. If you leave the dough to rise for too long, it will begin to smell and taste like yeast or beer and will eventually deflate or rise poorly in the oven with a light crust.

How can you tell if bread is Overproofed?

Step 1: Use the fingertip test to ensure that your dough is not overproofed. The test consists of lightly pushing your finger into the surface of the dough for 2 seconds and then watching how soon it bounces back. If the dough is overproofed, the dent you produce will be permanent.

Why is my bread not soft and fluffy?

Over or under-kneaded dough is one of the most prevalent causes of thick bread. Kneading your dough has a direct impact on gas generation since it accelerates fermentation. Bread dough will take significantly longer to ferment if it is not kneaded.

Can yeast dough be overworked?

While underworked dough may be remedied with a little extra kneading, badly overworked dough cannot. Instead, the overworked dough will produce a hard loaf that will most likely be discarded. It’s critical not to overwork your dough, and you should keep an eye out for it during the kneading process.

How much yeast do I need for 1 cup of flour?

Use 12 teaspoon yeast per cup of flour on standard cycle machines. The amount may be 2-3X more for one-hour or express machines. Only 34 teaspoon of active dry yeast per cup of flour may be substituted for the standard cycle. In certain brands, quick yeast and bread machine yeast may be used interchangeably in recipes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top