Which Flour Is Best for Cookies?

Which Flour Is Best for Cookies?

Rate this post

A new batch of cookies has several essential elements, ranging from the leavening agent to the eggs, butter, and sugar. However, one of the most noticeable elements is flour. But which flour is better for cookies?

If you’re planning on baking some cookies this weekend, don’t just use standard flour.

While all-purpose flour cannot be beat, you may use cake or bread flour for a superior alternative. Yes, the outcomes will vary, but not necessarily in a negative manner!

Hello, cookie enthusiasts! Shea here, and today I’d want to discuss flour with you. More importantly, what flour should you use for your cookies? Personally, I use AP flour on a daily basis with no problems. But there are plenty of other excellent options.

Keep reading to discover which flour ranked!

Which Flour Is Best for Cookies: Top Five Picks

Flour serves as the foundation for all of your culinary efforts, including a batch of cookies. That is why it is critical to follow your cookie recipe exactly, using the precise quantity of flour specified. But which flour is ideal for baking cookies? Let’s have a look at the top five possibilities.

1. All-Purpose Flour (Top Choice)

All-purpose flour, sometimes known as AP flour, is the most common kind of flour found in people’s kitchens. It’s the go-to ingredient for deep-frying chicken, air-frying zucchini chips, and, yes, baking cookies.

Protein content in all-purpose flour normally ranges from 10% to 12%. This ensures that your cookie has structure without being overly dense.

The end result? Perfect cookies with a little crunchy surface and a softly chewy middle. Most people consider it the ideal cookie, so while baking cookie delights, stick to all-purpose flour.

2. Cake Flour (Tender Cookies)

Some individuals dislike the idea of a crispy or chewy cookie. If you want a delicate and fluffy cookie that practically comes apart in your hands, cake flour is a good option.

Cake flour has the lowest protein concentration (about 6% to 7%), resulting in the weakest gluten structure. When you use cake flour, you can anticipate unbelievably flaky and delicious cookies.

If you’re concerned about your cookies crumbling, use half cake flour and half all-purpose flour. This will offer adequate structure while yet producing a fluffy product.

3. Bread Flour (Chewiest Cookie)

What is bread flour? This may seem to be an unusual ingredient to use in cookie making, but it works like magic. This is particularly true if you like a chewy cookie. Indeed, one might argue that it is nearly too chewy.

Why? This is due to the high protein level (up to 14%). All of the added protein contributes to a stronger gluten network, which is ideal for loaves of bread that need to be somewhat thicker and denser than a treat.

Use bread flour if you want perfectly delicious chewy cookies!

4. Self-Rising Flour (Tall and Fluffy Cookies)

One advantage of using self-rising flour is that you don’t have to worry about adding a leavening ingredient like baking soda or powder. Fewer ingredients are generally easier to handle, right?

Aside from shortening the ingredient list, self-rising flour is ideal for making exceptionally tall cookies. Self-rising flour may be your key to success if you prefer towering cookies versus standard flat circles.

Self-rising flour will also provide a fluffier and cakier overall texture. Again, this isn’t always a negative thing, particularly if you like a cake-like cookie.

5. Pastry Flour (Perfect In-Between)

Pastry flour is the last choice for making cookies. It falls in between cake flour and all-purpose flour in terms of protein level (about 8%).

Keeping this in mind, pastry flour is great for individuals looking for a more sensitive cookie that isn’t so fragile that it comes apart soon.

As a result, many people consider pastry flour to be the ideal and greatest option for making cookies. The main disadvantage is that pastry flour is more costly and harder to buy in local grocery shops, so it is often disregarded.


I’m sure you had no idea you had so many cookie-baking alternatives! I discovered a few often asked questions that you may be interested in knowing the answers to. Take a look at them down below!

Does it matter what flour you use for cookies?

It is undeniably significant. The structure of your cookies is made of flour. Using a different sort of flour, for example, can alter the texture, look, and taste. So, decide on the consistency of your cookies and continue from there. If you can’t decide, AP flour will always suffice.

Do you use plain flour or self-raising flour for cookies?

For cookies, you may use either self-rising flour or regular flour (all-purpose flour). Self-rising flour, on the other hand, spreads less, resulting in taller cookies. When compared to regular flour, the texture may be fluffier and lighter.

Is cake flour better for cookies?

50 if you use all-purpose flour. This will provide structure to your batch of cookies, which may be essential.If you want fluffy and light cookies that taste like a piece of cake, use cake flour instead of all-purpose flour. However, I suggest traveling 50 miles per hour.

How do you bake cookies so soft?

There are several methods for making soft cookies. Preheat your oven to 375°F. Underbake them for one minute (and no more). Add a teaspoon of cornstarch or a teaspoon of baking powder. Use cake flour and avoid overmixing!

Final Words

For cookies, all-purpose flour is preferable, although pastry flour is a close second. You may, however, substitute bread, cake, or self-rising flour. Because these flours can influence the final product, it is critical to understand the implications before using them in your cookie recipe.

What is your favorite flour to use while baking cookies? Please share in the comments section!


What flour do professional bakers use for cookies?

Pastry Flour – Like bread flour, pastry flour is milled from soft wheat and has a low gluten level. With protein levels that fall in between cake flour and all-purpose flour (8-9%), pastry flour achieves the optimal balance of flakiness and softness in pie dough, biscuits, brownies, tarts, and many cookies.

Does the type of flour matter in cookies?

The quantity and kind of flour used in cookies may determine whether they are chewy or cakey, crispy or soft. Cake flour is a lower-protein flour, with 7% to 9% protein vs 10% to 12% protein in all-purpose flour. When you combine the cookie dough with 100% cake flour, less gluten is created.

Is bread flour or all-purpose flour better for cookies?

Bread flour has more protein and gluten, making it ideal for making an airy, chewy bread that requires time to rise. All-purpose flour has a reduced protein level, making it ideal for non-rising cookies and cakes.

What flour do professional bakers use?

Pastry flour falls in between cake flour and all-purpose flour. Professional bakers adore how finely milled it is, with a protein concentration that ranges from 8% to 9%, finding the right balance between flakiness and softness while keeping structure.

How does all-purpose flour affect cookies?

Flour acts as a stabilizer and thickening, regulating how much the cookie rises. It binds the cookie together and gives it structure. If you use too little flour, your cookie will not hold its form, but if you use too much, you will get a thick, flavorless cookie.

Is self rising flour better for cookies?

2 teaspoon baking powder per cup flour should plenty.If you have a cookie recipe that uses all-purpose flour and spreads a lot, it’s usually not a good idea to use self-rising flour. However, any cookie with regular spread – one that has at least 1

What flour is best for chewy cookies?

When I want a chewy texture, I use bread flour. More gluten is produced when the protein concentration increases.

What makes cookies rise more?

Baking soda. The sort of leavening you use in your cookies impacts not just their rise but also their texture and structure. Baking soda produces a denser cookie with craggy topping, but baking powder enables cookies to rise higher during baking, resulting in a cakier texture.

Which is better for baking cookies bleached or unbleached flour?

Cookies, pancakes, waffles, quick breads, and pie crusts all benefit from bleached flour. Unbleached flour, on the other hand, is better suited for puff pastries, eclairs, yeast breads, and popovers.

What is the healthiest flour for cookies?

The Healthiest Baking Flours
The flour made from coconut. Coconut flour, which is created by grinding dried coconut flesh into a powder, is a grain-free and gluten-free alternative.
Oatmeal flour. Oat flour, manufactured from ground-up rolled oats, is a gluten-free whole-grain flour.
Quinoa meal.
Flour made from buckwheat.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top