Why does my bread have a sour taste?

Why does my bread have a sour taste?

Rate this post

Unless you’re baking sourdough bread, you don’t want your bread to taste sour, and even then, too much sourness isn’t necessarily desirable. But what happens if your bread has a sour flavor? What happened wrong, and how can it be avoided in the future?

There are many reasons why bread tastes sour. The most important reason is that you used much more yeast than was recommended. Another possibility is that it fermented for too long. Stale yeast or underbaking are two less prevalent causes.

Hello, bread connoisseurs! My name is Shea, and I love making bread just as much as I do eating it. I’ve encountered some unappealingly sour bread in my many years of baking. I’m here to tell you what went wrong and how to avoid it in the future.

Let’s get rid of that sour taste in your mouth!

Why Does My Bread Taste Sour? (4 Reasons)

There are four factors that might cause your loaf of bread to have a sour taste. Understanding what caused it might help you avoid it in the future. (Isn’t it true that being proactive is always the greatest thing to do?)

That being stated, let’s look at the four main explanations for sour bread.

1. Too Much Yeast

Yeast is the creamy heart of an Oreo cookie. Although creating bread without yeast is feasible with the aid of another leavening agent, yeast is the standard go-to and recommended product.

Yet too much of anything, even yeast, is never a healthy thing.

For a variety of reasons, people may add more yeast than is required. For example, people may desire their bread dough to rise quickly and believe that yeast is the secret to quick fermentation. Or maybe they accidentally added too much yeast.

Despite the reason, an overabundance of yeast will result in a sour taste. This is due to yeast producing lactic and acetic acids, which provide a sour flavor.

2. Over-Proofing

Absolutely, yeast is essential for successful bread making. Nonetheless, proofreading is also necessary. Over-proofing your dough may result in a variety of negative side effects, including collapsed loaves, bread that smells like alcohol, and, yes, sour bread.

Once again, the yeast produces lactic and acetic acids during fermentation. Undoubtedly, some of these acids are necessary for a beautiful and tasty bread. Too much acid, on the other hand, will result in an overly sour taste.

Allowing your dough to ferment for an extended period of time allows the yeast to continue creating lactic and acetic acids.

3. Stale Yeast

For two main reasons, stale or expired yeast should be avoided. For one thing, stale yeast will not perform as well as new, active yeast. It involves allowing the dough to proof for a lengthy period of time, which might result in sourness.

The second difficulty is that old yeast has a sour taste from the start, even before it penetrates your dough. When you start with sour yeast, you can only anticipate one thing: sour bread.

4. Under-Baking

Uncooked bread may have sour smells as well as a strong alcohol odor. Again, we can thank yeast for this.

Some of the sour, yeasty, and alcoholic smells and odors are baked away while your bread bakes. If you don’t bake your bread long enough, extra acids and bacteria might form, resulting in a sour flavor.

How to Prevent Bread That Tastes Sour

Bread with a sour taste that comes out of the oven is pretty much a done thing. It is entirely up to you whether or not to ingest it. Therefore, you must use extreme caution with your next loaf. Here are a few tips for avoiding sour bread.

1. Don’t Add Too Much Yeast

The easiest way to avoid sour bread is to avoid using too much yeast. Always follow the instructions exactly and do not add half a teaspoon extra. Consider acquiring and utilizing a kitchen scale to ensure you’re 100% exact and don’t mistakenly add too much yeast.

2. Don’t Over-Proof

Allowing your bread to proof is crucial, I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. Don’t attempt to get away with it. You should, however, avoid going excessive.

Most bread will prove in one to three hours at 75 degrees Fahrenheit, while some people like to proof their bread in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours. Although this is totally OK, I do not advocate beyond the proofing time of 24 hours.

Likewise, while your bread dough ferments, keep an eye on it. It is ready to bake when it has doubled in size and does not bounce back when touched.

3. Use Active Yeast

Did you know you may use a simple test to determine if your yeast is active? Just combine one teaspoon of sugar, one envelope of yeast (2 teaspoons), and one cup of water in a cup or jar. After ten minutes, if the yeast is active, it will create bubbles and a yeasty odor.

If you discover that your yeast is no longer active, discard it and replace it immediately. You won’t have to worry about using old, inactive yeast, which may cause sourness.

4. Bake It For the Right Amount of Time

Since each bread recipe is unique, it is vital to follow it from start to finish. Yet, most bread will bake in less than an hour. The goal is to ensure that the bread is thoroughly cooked. Using a bread machine may help reduce the amount of guessing.

You may test the doneness of your bread by tapping it on the counter. If it sounds hollow, it’s done and ready to be removed from the oven. It should also have a lovely golden brown crust and peel away from the pan’s edges.

Use a bread-baking thermometer for more precision. Most bread is done when it reaches an internal temperature of 190F, while other breads, such as those containing butter and eggs, must reach 200F.


You should now understand why your bread has a sour taste. More importantly, you know how to avoid it in the future. If you’re still interested to learn more, I have a few fascinating questions you may like to read.

How do you get the sour taste out of bread?

After it’s baked, there’s not much you can do except grit your teeth and eat it or throw it and start again. But, you may experiment with sourdough bread and modify the sourness before baking it in the oven or using a bread machine.

Here are a few tips for taming the sour taste in your sourdough: Use white flour instead of wheat flour to balance the acids, get rid of hooch on your sourdough starter, don’t de-gas, and opt for a slower, warmer fermentation.

Can you eat sour-smelling bread?

It should be absolutely acceptable to eat as long as there are no other signs that the bread is unhealthy to eat, such as mold, strange flavors beyond the sourness, or being as hard as a rock.

Bread Can Taste Sour for Many Reasons!

Needless to say, bread may have a sour taste for a variety of reasons, the most common of which is that you employed too much yeast. To prevent too sour outcomes, always strictly adhere to your bread recipe.

Have you ever prepared a sour loaf of bread? How did you avoid it? Do you have any advice or techniques to offer?


Can you eat bread that tastes sour?

Can you eat sourdough bread? You certainly can. It includes lactic acid, which is required for it to rise, and acetic acid, which makes it sour, both of which are abundant in nutrient-dense sourdough bread [2]. If that flavor is too sour for you, you may sweeten it with sugar, butter, salt, or honey.

How do you get the sour taste out of bread?

Baking soda balances out the sour flavor of sourdough bread. Baking soda boosts the rising power of the dough, but since it is such a powerful alkaline, it neutralizes the acids in the sourdough, which also neutralizes the sour taste.

Why does my bread smell sour but no mold?

This is often caused by bread that has passed its Best Before Date or by wild yeast infection.

Why does bread suddenly taste weird?

If you stored the bread in an overly humid environment or exposed it to a heat increase, even if just briefly, it may undermine its preservation, giving it a “strange flavor.” Even if you can’t detect mold with your eyes, flavor distinction is an indication that food is spoiling.

Should I eat bread that smells sour?

The sour odor is caused by yeast at work. If it’s over-proofed, the baked off product may have more air pockets than intended, but it should be good otherwise.

Is it OK if bread smells sour?

Before baking, the bread was fermented by yeast and contained alcohol. There may be trace levels of vinegar if the bread was slightly underbaked and picked up the correct bacteria. Another possibility is that the bread picked up a typical sourdough-like bacterium and now smells sour without actually containing acetic acid.

Does moldy bread taste sour?

Moldy bread has a sour and bitter aftertaste, but it is difficult to distinguish this slight difference since similar qualities are also present when one’s mouth becomes dry from eating too much salt.

How do you know if the bread is spoiled?

Visible mold or white, black, blue, or green patches on the bread indicate that it has rotted and should be discarded. Remove any store-bought bread that smells like vinegar, yeast, or even alcohol.

Does moldy bread have a rancid taste?

Mold imparts an off-flavor to bread, may induce allergic responses, and can cause dangerous infections, especially if you have a weakened immune system. As a result, you should never consume or smell it knowingly.

Why does my bread smell and taste like vinegar?

Bread emitting a vinegary odor is normal and not cause for alarm. Over-fermentation of the dough or mixing multiple acidic elements in a recipe causes it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top